How to choose a prop firm: the four figures that decide
Price is the figure traders compare and the one that matters least. The drawdown type, the consistency rule, the real cost and the payout terms decide whether an account survives.
What matters most when choosing a prop firm?
The drawdown calculation, not the price. A limit fixed at the starting balance and one that follows the account upward behave completely differently on identical figures, and the second ends far more accounts. Price is the easiest thing to compare and the least decisive.
Is a cheaper evaluation a better deal?
Not on its own. Across the 1,092 account sizes recorded here, a 100,000 account ranges from $9 to $4,500, and the cheap end often carries tighter rules, an activation fee on funding, or a paid reset. The real cost is the fee plus everything charged before the first payout.
How many prop firms impose a consistency rule?
Of the 53 firms recorded here, 37 impose a consistency rule on at least one program and 15 publish none at all. The rule caps how much of the total profit may come from a single day, so a trader who has one very good day must keep trading to dilute it.
Most comparisons of prop firms start with price, because price is the one figure every firm advertises in large type. It is also the figure that decides the least. A trader who picks the cheapest evaluation and loses the account to a drawdown rule they did not read has not saved anything.
Start with how the drawdown is calculated
A drawdown is the loss limit: breach it and the account closes. Firms calculate it in ways that are not comparable to each other, and the type matters more than the figure.
A static drawdown is fixed at the starting balance. The floor is known on day one and never moves, so every gain increases the distance to it. 10 of the 53 firms here use a static drawdown on every program.
A trailing drawdown follows the account upward. End-of-day trailing moves once a day on the closing balance. Intraday trailing moves on the highest point reached during the session, including profit that was never banked, so a position that goes well and comes back can raise the floor without the gain ever being realised. 15 firms here use intraday trailing on at least one program.
Two firms can publish the same loss limit on the same account size and present a trader with completely different risks. Read the type first.
Then read the consistency rule
A consistency rule caps how much of the total profit may come from a single day, commonly between 20 and 50 per cent. Its stated purpose is to filter out traders who pass on one lucky position. Its practical effect is that a very good day must be diluted by more trading, which can turn a passed evaluation into a longer one.
37 of the 53 firms here impose one on at least one program. 15 publish none. For a trader whose edge produces occasional large days, that difference is worth more than any price gap.
Work out the real cost, not the advertised one
The advertised fee is rarely the whole cost. 58 of the 1,092 account sizes recorded here carry an activation fee charged when a passed evaluation becomes a funded account, and 17 firms charge for a reset after a failed attempt. Some firms add a monthly data fee on top.
The honest comparison is the fee plus everything charged before the first payout, which is what the cost calculator on this site works out. A $99 evaluation with a $149 activation fee costs more than a $199 evaluation with none.
Finally, read the payout terms
A profit split is a headline; the payout terms decide when a trader sees money. What matters is when a payout may first be requested, how often it may be repeated, and whether a minimum applies. A firm paying 90 per cent every fortnight on demand is a different proposition from one paying 90 per cent after thirty days and a minimum balance.
Many firms publish a maximum split reached only after a scaling plan or several payouts. The figure a new trader is paid is the initial split, which is why both are recorded here.
What not to choose on
Not on a score, including the ones comparison sites invent. No score can weigh a drawdown type against a consistency rule for a particular trader, and any site publishing one is choosing the weights for you without saying so.
Not on a discount code either. A verified code is worth having, and it says nothing about whether the rules suit the way you trade.
Check it against the data
Every figure quoted above comes from the database behind this site, where each one carries the address of the firm page it was read on and the date it was read. Compare all firms, every account size, or read how the data is collected.